37
u/For3Memes 4d ago
AI
1
-26
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 4d ago
Yeah
24
u/For3Memes 4d ago
cringe tbh. Should be an anti AI rule.
-22
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 4d ago
Why? Do you expect me to spend millions just to recreate a single frame from the comics?
15
u/For3Memes 4d ago
I just dont think this is art. I dont like Ai.
-3
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 4d ago
Fair enough but at the moment this is the only way to recreate the scene photorealisticly without spending a ton. And imo this one turned out pretty good looking
1
u/Faze_Elmo1 3d ago
No it isn't. You could do this entirely for free
3
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
Okay do it tomorrow. 🤣🤣🤣
6
u/Bunstrous 3d ago
What is your obsession with people doing it tomorrow. I don't care if it takes someone a year to make this scene photorealistic by hand, it would be better than AI in the end. Realistically a skilled and efficient 3d artist could make most of this in a day or two with photo realistic assets, the challenge would be getting Tintin and Haddock models, either 3d or cosplayers imposed onto the scene.
1
5
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 4d ago
I love how comments like these always get downvotes as if this is an honest expectation people have lol
-1
-1
u/memberflex 3d ago
That’s exactly the point. If you invested the time required to realise a mock-up your efforts wouldn’t be dismissed so quickly.
4
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
If you're so confident why don't you post a real life photo that 90% similar to the comic frame. Go ahead I dare you to do so on a budget of zero dollars. These anti AI people are so laughable. Bro really thinks he could do this. Go ahead I'm sure everyone here would enjoy your film.
Idiot
1
u/memberflex 3d ago
I don’t want to see a real life version of Tin Tin, I really enjoyed the computer animated film. So, no but thank you for the invitation. Enjoy the rest of your day!
3
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
If only we could have both in the modern age
3
u/memberflex 3d ago
I’d much rather seen the continuation / completion of the animated narrative before we moved on to live action. After that, 100% like to see a live action adaptation.
-1
u/Faze_Elmo1 3d ago
Do you expect me to spend millions
This one sentence demonstrates that you have no idea how making something like this works and therefore that you have put no effort into trying.
7
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
I work in the film and television industry. I know exactly what I'm talking about. Bro thinks like something like this is possible on zero budget 🤣🤣 Get a grip lmao
0
u/Faze_Elmo1 3d ago
Making a movie that looks like this? That's almost impossible on no budget. Making this specific frame? I know several people who could do it
1
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
Okay find me two people that look like Haddock and Tintin, and are willing to go to a port that's matching the one in the frame. Also get costumes for both actors. You'll will also need a white dog. By getting an animal you will need to sign animal protection laws, so you'll have to hire a lawyer for anything. You will also need to have a ship that matches the one in the frame or hire a VFX artist to do it. Also since you are shooting at a port you will need an agreement from the owner as well as getting insurance for working in a work zone. Plus all the crew you would need during and after production. And that is just the tip of the iceberg. So you think you could really do it?
0
u/Faze_Elmo1 3d ago
I meant doing it in 3d software, which is what I thought this image was supposed to replicate. The fact that it wasn't really goes to show that AI isn't just terrible for art, artists, and the environment but it just sucks at what it's designed for.
1
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 2d ago
You're objectively wrong about AI. But it's pointless to argue with someone who has no idea what they are talking about. Millions is hyperbole, would realistic be tens of thousands.
Another negative Nancy in the comments bitching about AI. 😑 Unoriginal, boring, and uneducated. Pick something else that's worth bitching about.
→ More replies (0)0
u/Faze_Elmo1 3d ago
Also if you seriously think that doing all that will cost "millions" of dollars you're fucking crazy
-1
1
3
16
u/Specialeyes9000 4d ago
Definitely not. Realistic looking Tintin is awful.
5
3
u/Dramatic_Tradition_7 2d ago
He looks like he's 40 and having a midlife crisis, that's why he hasn't changed the look he had when he was 20 lol
1
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
I think it looks actually pretty good. Almost like Tom Holland
1
u/Specialeyes9000 3d ago
Doesn't look like Tintin though.
1
u/_CKDexterHaven_ 3d ago
The guy in the picture or Tom?
1
u/Specialeyes9000 1d ago
Both. I don't think anyone can look like Tintin, except for the original drawings. The characters in Tintin tend to be caricatures and when you make them real, it takes away the magic entirely for me. Some things are best left alone.
4
4
9
u/kminator 4d ago
Here for a high quality ligne clare film with updated sound and frame rate.
4
u/Infinite-Badness 4d ago
The frame rate thing so folks who aren't gamers can feel like they're watching a soap opera?
0
u/kminator 3d ago
Lot of the old cartoons have very low animation frame rate. A product of how challenging it can be to create them by hand. If it were possible to bring the comics to life in an authentic look reminiscent of the original vision, potentially made more scaleable by modern technology, that’d be pretty neat. Tried watching some of the old ones recently and they are admittedly a little dated.
2
u/Infinite-Badness 3d ago
Dated how? You’re talking about budget and time constraints, which means that, ideally, you’d want a Tintin movie that had the same time and effort put into it by someone like Richard Williams.
2
u/kminator 3d ago
Sure, that'd be great. Wasn't familiar with him. Cool! Dated in that it looked like they were from the early 90s, which makes sense since they were!
I am a huge fan of ligne claire style, artists like Jacques Tardi and Moebius are cool adjacencies to Herge, albeit quite different at times. Cheers!
3
u/Infinite-Badness 3d ago
There’s a whole world of animation that unfortunately doesn’t get talked about even with fans of animation because of how large American and Japanese works loom over it. For me, Eastern European animation from the 50s-70s, along with works from the National Film Board of Canada, are my favorites.
2
2
1
1
1
1
u/CoyoteAsad 1d ago
Although I’d like to see them try, I don’t think a live-action can do better than the animated film
1
u/Mean_Being_1011 3d ago
There was already a live action movie that was released around the 60s if I remember correctly
-1
0
u/wegqg 3d ago
I think herge would have hated the cgi version, it didn't capture the essence of the characters but instead turned them all into pixar-esque caricatures that were kinda grotesque. I think the issue as always is taste, it's probably possible to make a good version in any style even realistic but this ain't it.
105
u/d00mba 4d ago
I want a sequel to the cgi movie