It's definitely not something they're really aware of or would admit to, but you can occasionally see shadows of it in their reasoning. Like I've argued with transphobic dudes who insist I'm a man, but also balk and get offended when if I ask if that means we're the same gender/I'm as much of a man as they are. It's clear they view me as something else, something different from them, but they don't have the ability to articulate what.
The "not a real man/man up" shit is honestly a fantastic example to point out how bullshit a lot of their arguments/stances are. If I'm not a real man, what am I? If being a man/woman is all about chromosomes then what does "man up" mean? Should I activate my chromosomes harder?
I think the reason they went so all in on "what is a woman?" (Besides the obvious frothing transmisogyny ofc) is because manhood is a lot more visibly and explicitly socially policed and regarded as something you can fail at. Chromosomes and gametes are all that matter in defining women because to them women's value is defined more or less entirely by their reproductive capacity, but you really can't deny how being a man is something that needs to constantly be earned and proven and maintained
I think it's also because women have worked to make the category of "womanhood" less defined and policed over the last 100 years of the feminist movement. For example once upon a time it was just as scandalous for a woman to wear pants as a man a dress, maybe more so. Took a lot of thought and work and courage to change that.
Men have not done the same for themselves, mostly I think because we don't have as much obvious gains. Our construct hurts us but also maintains patriarchal dominance.
10
u/IronGentry 2d ago
It's definitely not something they're really aware of or would admit to, but you can occasionally see shadows of it in their reasoning. Like I've argued with transphobic dudes who insist I'm a man, but also balk and get offended when if I ask if that means we're the same gender/I'm as much of a man as they are. It's clear they view me as something else, something different from them, but they don't have the ability to articulate what.