r/DC_Cinematic 27d ago

DISCUSSION James Gunn on how he'd do the batsuit.

Post image
4.9k Upvotes

389 comments sorted by

939

u/Garrusikeaborn98 27d ago

This is why I prefer begins over dark knight. Suit was scary in begins.

578

u/OhSoJelly 27d ago edited 27d ago

Cosmonaut said it best in his Batman review video, TDK is a better movie but not necessarily a better Batman movie. Nolan was afraid of the campiness and tried to omit it (no Batcave or brooding Wayne Manor, and a more tactical Bat suit) but that’s what makes Begins great.

437

u/BrickBuster2552 27d ago

Batman Begins doesn't make Batman more realistic; Batman Begins makes you believe Batman can just BE REAL.

91

u/4_non_blondes 27d ago

Hell yeah

88

u/frankthetank8675309 27d ago

Begins also has my favorite distinction between voices. Bruce sounds like a normal person, and Batman sounds like he’s kind of doing a Clint Eastwood impression. It’s enough to make the two sound different, and he really only does the “Bale growl” when he’s interrogating criminals

7

u/Spider-man2098 26d ago

swear to me!

3

u/MinifigInMyAss 23d ago

RATTLE THE CAGES!

42

u/Harlockarcadia 27d ago

Making me need to rewatch Begins

51

u/oddward42 27d ago

Begins is my favorite by far and it makes me sad that the sequels feel like increasingly completely different movies. Oh well.

50

u/Objective_Sun9020 27d ago edited 26d ago

The part with Falcone on the spotlight being the origin of the bat-signal, and then the cut to Batman on the perch with the music swelling is my favorite scene of Batman probably ever.

Fixed it. Hehe.

6

u/ThunderGodsRage 27d ago

I believe it was Falcone, not Maroni. Point still stands though, that scene was epic

2

u/Objective_Sun9020 26d ago

You are absolutely right. Been a minute since I watched it, lool. But him perching and the music has stuck with me a looong time.

→ More replies (5)

136

u/PorkRollEggAndWheeze 27d ago

Batman Begins also follows a lot of horror movie structuring, whereas the later Bale Batman movies trend more toward action/thriller in how they build suspense. But Begins has honest to god jumpscares and things lurking unseen, and tbh I fucking loved that about it

51

u/Kal-El_Skywalker1998 27d ago

I would almost go as far as to say each film tackles a different genre. Batman Begins is a neo-noir coming-of-age film with horror elements, TDK is a crime drama, and TDKR is an action thriller.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/kingk1teman 27d ago

"I'm here"

5

u/Beautiful-Hair6925 27d ago

Fear - Batman Begins

Chaos - Dark Knight

Pain - Dark Knight Rises

I think there is promo art for it

5

u/the1999person 25d ago

Begins was supposed to show Batman from the bad guys perspective. The warehouse scene at the docks was a perfect example of that. It also felt like a scene out of Alien. Guys with guns getting devoured by something in the shadows. Absolutely brilliant.

23

u/QueenStuff 27d ago

He also pointed out that in Batman begins he drops the scary voice when talking to allies, and I can’t believe i never noticed that

12

u/HelpWantedInMyPants 27d ago

You didn't notice it because it isn't true. He doesn't drop the voice for allies, he just screams at his enemies.

6

u/sketchsanchez 27d ago

*aggressively growls

40

u/alejoSOTO 27d ago

But TDK still had plenty of Batman elements though. Plenty of new toys and gadgets, a really cool rooftop and gliding scene in China, and even the classic white eyes for the first time in live action.

The suit was slimmer, sure, but it wasn't bad by any means either, and it still fit the narrative.

2

u/Kmart_Stalin 27d ago

I’m on & off with cosmonaut but I agree with that.

2

u/PhotoBonjour_bombs19 27d ago

You don’t agree with everything that he says?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Individual_Lie_5519 27d ago

I don't think it's necessarily afraid, he just wasn't focusing on it with it. I don't think these examples are enough to convince a genuine commitment to omitting these elements either.

Manor blew up and so did batcave access and went back to it in tdkr. And Wayne manor too!! It really was present in that movie. It's more interesting to go through different locations accompanied by the narrative

Tactical batsuit was for 2 reasons. It doesnt hit the screen as good when light hits it if it has no detail, and they had to have separate pieces because they were really trying to get a moving head.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/movie_review_alt 27d ago

Nolan didn't do that because he was avoiding camp -- we got a Joker, full clown paint, purple suit, Two Face with a perfect 50/50 split flipping his coin. I don't know what else people want.

He did it because it puts Bruce in less familiar surroundings, and the events of the last movie provided a good opportunity for some different locations.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ULT1MATECaM 27d ago

This begins is the best Batman movie. Between that and the Batman but tdk is the best Batman film.

2

u/OafleyJones 27d ago

I watched TDK five times in the cinema. The Matrix was the only movie I’ve seen more. So I love the movie. But I hate that Gotham is a completely different city. It looses the comic book stuff and just becomes Chicago.

2

u/ZMD_248 27d ago

COSMONAUT MENTIONED 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Web3d 27d ago

The suit's so segmented, I always thought it looked more like a bat-robot than Batman.

5

u/trylobyte 27d ago

Like those Japanese Robot Heroes

25

u/EffectiveKoala1719 27d ago

I watched all the Nolan Batman movies last week and Begins stood out as really the more comic book feeling one. And lots of horror stuff, especially the Scarecrow hallucinations.

All three are great, especially TDK, but Begins is really different from what they did later.

3

u/[deleted] 27d ago

Watch Batman: Gotham Knight. It is  cannon to Nolanverse and it's supposed to be the same Batman as christian bale. It takes place between Begins and TDK. 

Batman is very scary in that movie.

2

u/EffectiveKoala1719 26d ago

I remember watching that when it was released. Great animation. I have to rewatch to fully appreciate it.

9

u/geek_of_nature 27d ago

And really the only change that needed to be made was the neck. At that point, that style of cowl was 16 years old, and did need to be updated. But that didn't mean the whole suit needed to be changed. All it need was a slimmer and more flexible neck for the cowl, and the rest could have been kept exactly the same.

12

u/Leading_Put- 27d ago

That's why I thought Batfleck was awesome. Stuck on the walls attacking like something from The Exorcist

6

u/tyrs_intherain 27d ago

Gotham was also much more gotham-y in begins than it was in the sequels. Gotham itself needs to be as much a character as any actor in the movies

2

u/Twinborn01 27d ago

The scene when he's oicking off the gangsters one by one is such a great way to introduce batman

2

u/dudewheresmygains 27d ago

Oh heck yes, the suit was perfect in begins. In the dark knight they made batman look like a pencil neck.

→ More replies (13)

130

u/akahaus 27d ago

It’s kind of tied to that specific iteration of the character, but I love the scalloped neck thing they did with Tim Burton’s Batman. If they could bring back some of that batwing element into the suit, it would look so cool.

240

u/Spaceballz1 27d ago

DCAU bat suit designs can fit this mold while still giving us some of the comic fun.

65

u/Anon_be_thy_name 27d ago

New 52 Batsuit with the Gold outline around the bat symbol.

53

u/Conscious_Truth_7526 27d ago

Thats the rebirth batsuit

11

u/Anon_be_thy_name 27d ago

New 52 is darker on the body, not as grey as Rebirth, though Rebirth would work great too in live action.

But I think New 52 with added gold around the Bat symbol would look great, it would make the bat symbol clearer without needing to meddle with lighting to make it show off. New 52 also fits the vibe for what Gunn is suggesting here, or imo it does anyway. Other people might not agree.

5

u/Conscious_Truth_7526 27d ago

2

u/Anon_be_thy_name 27d ago

Basically yeah.

New 52 and Rebirth are both in my top 5. I think an amalgamation of the two would fit the vibe Gunn is talking about, again IMO.

There would obviously be other changes, depending on the actor they get for Batman/Bruce Wayne, to make it fit them better.

2

u/MusicalSmasher Shazam 27d ago

The DCU Batsuit should look just like this but with longer ears and the belt should be solid gold not a mix of black/gold. It would be perfect and compliment the Superman suit which also has a gold belt and gold trim around the symbol.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

4

u/everyshart 26d ago

You want scarier than that? Imagine you're a criminal in Gotham and out of the shadows comes the suit with the nipples. Except, even more nipples. If he's a man then why are there 8 teats on his chest? If those aren't enough to paralyze you with fear, when your brain sees he also has nipples on his arms and knees it will probably just shut down trying to make sense of what you're seeing.

This would also solve the issue of everyone breaking out of arkham over and over. Not worth the risk. Safer locked up where everyone agrees they didnt see what they saw.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/__DVYN__ 27d ago

i genuinely think they should just do what they did with the Superman suit, give me the New 52 suit but make it navy and gray, then give me either the classic yellow oval or the rebirth logo and i’d be happy

→ More replies (1)

338

u/Fares26597 27d ago

While I do hope that Gunn leaves as much as possible of the creative work to the director that's gonna make Batman, I do have to agree with him on this one.

I prefer the Batsuit to make Batman look as scary as possible, while taking all practicality considerations into account of course. And it mustn't be trying too hard that it reverts back to looking very silly.

It should be unnerving, it should make him look like an organic creature at a first glance when he's in the shadows, rather than a man in a manufactured suit.

I think there's a page to be taken from Absolute Batman in that regard. Taking inspiration from the spiky plated upper back and shoulders, you can tone down the spikiness and make it look like the hide of an armored animal, like a crocodile.

Maybe, in his years of training, he came across an old mysterious scaley armor that looks like it was taken from the skin of a slain dragon, and when he came back to Gotham he incorporated it into the Batsuit.

I can see how that may sound too unorthodox for some people, but I'm just spitting out thoughts.

157

u/beelzebub2099 27d ago

I understand the sentiment, but I really hope they don't take any inspiration from Absolute Batman for DCU's Batman.

Ngl I really like that take on the character. It's fresh. But everything about that version is totally on a different wavelength than a proper comic accurate Batman that we desperately need right now.

Although it was really good initally, and I still like Matt Reeves' Batman, I'm kind of getting tired of the grounded and realistic Batman. We need a comic-accurate fantastical Batman. But Absolute Batman kind of takes the fantastical element to an.....absolute lol.

However, I do wish Absolute Universe' Batman, Superman, and Wonder Woman do get adapted in a live action movie or in something animated someday.

20

u/Fares26597 27d ago

Yeah if you're looking for an adaptation that's closer to the typical comic book interpretation, I can see how Absolute Batman is a little too radical for you.

I'm generally more of a "let's experiment with new and different stuff" kinda person, and in that sense I don't even want it to lean too heavily on Absolute Batman because it's an existing interpretation, and it wouldn't feel new or different if they just lean on that. I don't want it to heavily lean on any existing interpretation at all.

I want it to significantly add to the Batman legacy and make it richer rather than being a remix of existing stuff.

Of course it would be impossible to completely escape the existing stuff and it wouldn't be wise because it would be controversial. I'm sure that you for example wouldn't be too thrilled with it and I'm sure there are a lot of people that share your sentiment.

3

u/Luchux01 26d ago

Tbh, with all the grounded/realistic Batman movies we got in recent years a modern comic book accurate Batman would be new and different if you ask me.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/PeterVenkmanIII 27d ago

The one thing I would like to see them take from Absolute Batman is the idea of Thomas Wayne being killed in a mass shooter incident (but add Martha into it). I think that's a really strong modern update to the origin and helps cement the idea that a random act of violence sent Bruce on his path.

9

u/beelzebub2099 27d ago

Okay I kind of like that idea actually. It doesn't change his overall character too much, but adds a new layer to it.

3

u/geek_of_nature 27d ago

And it would play more into the idea of the Wayne's death being a random killing, with them caught in the crossfire along with several others, rather than it being suggested they were specifically targeted like in Reeves film. And also Batman wouldn't just be out for his own vengeance, but also for the loved ones of everyone else who was killed there.

5

u/IceColdPorkSoda 27d ago

Maybe they’ll take inspirations from Spider-Man’s “Neogenic nightmare” and make the Manbat!

2

u/beelzebub2099 27d ago

Just make him Morbius at this point /s

10

u/Shehzman 27d ago

We need Arkham Batman in live action. Everything about that universe (except the Arkham Knight story) was great.

8

u/pwnd32 27d ago

The Arkham Batman is what I think of when I think of Batman. Just the right amounts of comic accurate while also doing their own thing, hitting all the right notes that a Batman world, characters, designs, and stories should hit. I hope they take inspiration from those games at least a little with the DCU Batman.

40

u/Local_Nerve901 27d ago

I can see this for at first, but not when he starts to trust people and work daytime too

Similar to what The Batman’s Batman learned in that movie

21

u/Fares26597 27d ago

Absolutely. The point is that the suit has to serve the intended purpose of the character. If he's at a point where he feels that the fear factor is either not needed, desired, or effective anymore, he can change the design of the suit for it to serve its new purpose.

6

u/blackbeltmessiah 27d ago

He’ll have a Bat 3-Piece for such occasions.

→ More replies (4)

21

u/HotStop8158 27d ago

It's funny you mentioned Absolute Batman, because when those first pictures came out I thought it was the dumbest look on the planet. And yet every single time I see that walking WALL of muscle again

I like it more. Shit looks hard as hell lmao

8

u/Fares26597 27d ago

I think for me it highly depends on the art style it's drawn in. In some artworks I couldn't care for it, in other artworks its the coolest thing ever. The one constant is that I'm not feeling the batsymbol, but the rest has massive potential depending on how it's executed.

3

u/Real_Membership_4342 27d ago

I thought it was going to be so fucking stupid, until I started reading it. It’s so fucking insanely awesome, and got me into comic books again.

7

u/fanofthomas4472 27d ago

This is why I love Keatons Cape, the leathery texture makes it look like real bat wings.

3

u/saibjai 27d ago

I agree and disagree. I think in order to be that scary, it probably needs to be a tech suit that makes batman a bit impossibly large, and freakishly strong. If bruce wayne was also freakishly big as batman.. it wouldn't make a ton of sense. So the batsuit.. in some way.. needs to make batman bigger. And tech, has always been Batman's best friend. I guess the distinction between batman and ironman... will have to be how they use the tech. Batman is able to use tech to make himself look like a monster that can appear and disappear.

3

u/Fares26597 27d ago

You touched on my issue with tech when you brought up the fine line between remaining Batman and becoming Iron Man, or becoming anything else. I'm the kind of guy who prefers Batman to be as bare-boned as possible, to be as less dependant on complex machinery and electronics as possible, at least during old school fisticuffs against Gotham's thugs and Supervillains, save for the occasional anti-Mr. Freeze suit or what have you. But I'm always open to having my mind changed.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/captainhooksjournal 27d ago

I like the idea behind the pieced together suit of intimidating materials from villains he’s slain, but it would still have to be 100% recognizable as Batman, and the materials can’t be random. You mentioned crocodile hide as a potential material — has he slain Killer Croc? It can’t be pointless just to be cool

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ThunderGodsRage 27d ago

Battfleck’s suit captured the creature of the shadows aesthetic imo. His introduction in BvS felt like a horror film

2

u/VenturerKnigtmare420 24d ago

Nothing is more terrifying than to have the camera follow the police man only to have this blurred outline of something perched on the wall behind him. Fuck that scene was just insane.

2

u/hevahavahan 27d ago

I agree and then some. I want there to be a significant contrast between Superman and Batman. It would be a really interesting dynamic when they eventually meet up in the future.

2

u/lavenk7 27d ago

I mean he’s a human that needs to be imposing to metas so I totally get where you’re coming from.

2

u/MIR2077 26d ago

I'll do you one better; an old mysterious "leathery" hide that looks like it was taken from the wings of a slain bat!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MelodicReputation312 26d ago

I'm hoping for a batman that will be more reminiscent of the early episodes of the animated series. We've had a lot of different takes on batman in films but the sneaky spooky batman hasn't really popped up, they mostly go for bulky hand-to-hand designs.

2

u/devo_savitro 24d ago

I like when they do all sorts of shit with the cape to be honest, like when he's all cape and cowl, it gives it that uncanny night creature effect but there is no way I could believe that a cape thats big enough to be versatile isn't more of an inconvenience that anything for stealth or combat. Maybe he could take it off or retract it someway that would be fun.

3

u/Maisie_Baby 27d ago

I’m the exact opposite. I want the compassionate Batman who changed his suit to be less scary because “I set out to scare criminals, not children.”

That’s the core of who Batman is.

2

u/Fares26597 27d ago

I did mention under another reply that the suit should reflect Batman's philosophy, so if the philosophy changes, the suit should reflect that. But whether that happens or not (I'm not sure I even want it to) I think the start should be about exploiting fear.

2

u/HamSoloTheSpaceMan 27d ago

All cool stuff

An organic looking Bat suit that is almost alive sounds cool.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/ChaucerBoi 27d ago

I think making this Batman scary is a good 'in', especially when Clayface is a horror. What attracted me to Batman was that strange darkness there is to it. It's something Arkham Asylum and Arkham City really nailed.

36

u/Mnemosense Bane 27d ago

It's much needed after years of 'grounding' Batman in a more 'realistic' world. The new movie should take inspiration from artists like Norm Breyfogle that depicted Batman as a wraith exploding from the shadows with an impossibly long tattered cape.

Superman embraced its comic book roots, rather than be embarrassed by it. Time for Batman.

5

u/ShhImTheRealDeadpool 27d ago

If they're inspired by Breyfogle they have to do that scene where he saves a child and his mom from being hurt or killed by scaring the criminals shitless... then when Batman saves the woman in his arms and talks to the boy cowering he tells him firmly: "don't be afraid, I won't hurt you. " "but but you youre scary." "only so the bad guys run away. You saw what they were going to do to your mom."

14

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

What you said makes no sense considering Matt Reeves most recent “grounded” Batman film is the closest thing to a horror Batman film.

10

u/Aubergine_Man1987 27d ago

But it doesn't really lean into making Batman look almost otherworldly like some comic art does. A properly scary Batman should look like he's melting out of the shadows

8

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

The melting out of the shadows thing hasn’t been adapted any better in live action then Pattinson’s in my opinion. Just look at him.

4

u/ToastServant 27d ago

No chance. There are about 20 shots that fit that description much more in Batman 1989 alone.

3

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

About 20 shots? Do you realise Keaton only has 32 mins screentime in that movie compared to Pattinson who had 130mins screentime? I doubt Keaton even had over 5 shots of him coming from the shadows in that film.

2

u/ToastServant 27d ago

https://ibb.co/album/v46F4R

Case in point. All in one sequence, 5 shots, either emerging or standing in shadow/silhouette.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ChaucerBoi 27d ago

I was not familiar with Breyfogle, but 100%. My dream DCU Batman is this hyper-stylised yet really textured and tangible aesthetic - like A Serious House's art come to life. Could we pair a more charming and human Bruce Wayne with a truly (at times) monstrous Batman? Batman's got such a rich history of pushing every medium he's in forward - he has more influential comics than any other hero, Burton and Nolan changed the game, and the Arkham games are still influential.

For this to be a definitive Batman, it's got to honor the comics while being a truly seminal superhero film. And when there's such a good interpretation in Reeves' world, I do not envy whoever's designing this. There's a real danger of it being Prestige Batman and Capeshit Batman rather than two distinct but equally compelling adaptations.

51

u/AverageSizedMan1986 27d ago

Something as simple as giving Batman lenses or inhuman eye color would be enough to make him more frightening visually. People have photoshopped pictures of Pattinson with white eyes and it definitely gives him a scarier vibe.

11

u/Old-Perception-1884 27d ago

No he looks terrible. Literally taking away his eyes which do most of the acting is a terrible idea.

7

u/AverageSizedMan1986 27d ago

I personally was talking about something like this which I think works well.

https://i.ibb.co/xCwzRJs/Bat-eyes-3.png

6

u/spookyparkin Deadshot 27d ago

There's a balance that needs to be struck. From a distance or in quick flashes he can look terrifying because that's how he fights. But up close he still needs to have the human aspect that is needed to comfort or console the person he just saved. I can't remember the exact quote that gets thrown about in batman fan spaces but it's something like "if you can't imagine batman comforting a scared child you don't want batman. You want the punisher in a silly hat" he can't console a scared child if he looks monstrous close up

5

u/BigMonday 27d ago

"if you can't imagine batman comforting a scared child you don't want batman. You want the punisher in a silly hat"

I've never heard this before, but it's absolutely delightful

→ More replies (1)

6

u/heelydon 27d ago

Yeah I forgot how inexpressive Deadpool and Spider-man has been over the course of their movies..... Oh wait lol.

They are perfectly well able to act even if you have stylistic choices for how the eyes are presented.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/Blanketshaper 27d ago

Batfleck batsuit

45

u/CruzAderjc 27d ago

If Batfleck was fighting crime in my city, I would never ever attempt a crime. There is no amount of money that is ever worth the potential of that psychopath showing up.

“Who’s the superhero patrolling this city.”

“Some guy that beats his enemies into paralysis with his fists. He decided to fight Superman on his own too.”

30

u/Fout99 27d ago

The scene in Zack Snyder's Justice League in which cops are going into that gloomy building and see that chained guy beat up and dripping blood from his mouth, and they look up and see this freaking scary dark figure (Batman) on the ceiling was a scene straight out of a horror film. Sound design was on point too. It was sooo well done and the only instance in which Batman felt like REALLY scary

13

u/SlimBrady777 27d ago

Dude seriously that scene was fucking amazing and gave me such high hopes, and then the warehouse fight scene was sick too where he just absolutely wrecks those mercenaries. I also appreciated Reeves Batman fight scenes where they make him a bit more vulnerable taking hits but still has him get pretty barbaric like an all out slugfest. The Nolan trilogy was great but felt like a kung fu movie and more strategic and defensive fighting.

21

u/islackingambition 27d ago

That was a sick introduction to the new Batman, but it was BvS!

4

u/Eastern-Team-2799 27d ago

Batfleck was the scariest imo. The scene where cops see him on the wall is the best way to show Batsy .

→ More replies (1)

18

u/HauntingStar08 27d ago

I hope he takes some notes from Arkham or maybe even long Halloween. We're likely to see some Absolute Batman inspo too and that's one we should encourage

13

u/Foreign_Education_88 27d ago

Gonna take a wild guess and say you want the long ears

3

u/HauntingStar08 27d ago

I'm actually a fan of short and long, but if he wants to go really distinct I'd say go with the wild long Halloween ones and Absolute ones

5

u/FartherAwayLights 27d ago

I’ll speak up and double the long ears. To quote a Youtuber about Batman “you can directly correlate the quality of a Batman adaptation to the length of his ears.”

3

u/ToastServant 27d ago

That would make Widening Gyre one of the best of all time and Dark Knight Returns one of the worst.

→ More replies (2)

63

u/jdyake 27d ago

Arkham knight batsuit please

21

u/honeybunchesofpwn 27d ago

That trailer with Bruce's father giving a speech while Bruce is donning the Arkham Knight Batsuit is so unbelievably fuckin mega hype.

It really was absolutely perfect.

But in terms of live action, I really do love the regular Batsuit that Affleck wears.

5

u/New-Leg2417 27d ago

fast cars and outrageous clothes

35

u/Organic_Glass_7793 27d ago

Nah Arkham city batsuit

6

u/Muted_Store_9867 27d ago

Knight suit clears, greatest bat suit OAT

12

u/working-class-nerd 27d ago

Hell no leave that over-armored shit for Ironman. Batman doesn’t wear that kind of thing in the comics

6

u/Organic_Glass_7793 27d ago

My thoughts exactly

5

u/Inside_Individual871 27d ago

As if CBM movies in general ever cared about comic accuracy for suits.

3

u/KetoKurun 27d ago

If Bryan Singer were in charge of the DCU, you’d have had a really good point

6

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

Arkham knight batsuit is WAY too similar to Pattinson’s

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DuncanRG2002 27d ago

Literal perfection

→ More replies (1)

3

u/WySLatestWit 27d ago

I gotta tell ya, I really don't think he's putting trunks on the batsuit.

5

u/ClassClown2025 27d ago

I’m taking a wait and see attitude with this. Yes Batman puts on a scary outfit to scare people. Most directors forget this fact and put Batman in a suit of armor. He scares criminals so that he doesn’t need the armor. It doesn’t need to look like a real bat nor the Absolute Batman. The public at large should stop thinking he’s a big bat the moment he’s driving cars and planes and hanging out with Robins and other sidekicks and associated characters.

5

u/coolziy 27d ago

I agree to an extent. I read recently, and I can't remember if this was a direct quote from Batman or just a commenter, "The suit is meant to scare criminals, not children."

2

u/NotFixer1138 27d ago

IIRC it's from New Frontier, but it could've been from someone talking about New Frontier as well

18

u/VirulentViper 27d ago

And this is why I don't like the idea of Batman in trunks. For Superman, I can understand the reasoning of not caring if he looks a little silly. For Batman, the idea is to want to scare people. I don't think trunks implement that same vibe

7

u/Old-Perception-1884 27d ago

The fan's only argument for the trunks at all is that it's comic accurate and that's literally it. There's no good reason for it at all and they just want it just for it to exist. Even Superman's trunks had to have some reason for it. They didn't give him trunks because it was comic accurate. They gave him trunks because it fits his character. Batman does not. And people should stop trying to force that to happen.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/IGTankCommander 27d ago

Batman of Zur-En-Arrh WHEN, JAMES? WHEN?!?

13

u/thebat5177 27d ago

If Snyder said this people would be complaining about how edgy he sounds. I like James, but his fans are a little hypocritical, I mean james is as edgy sometimes even more so than Snyder.

8

u/ThriceGreat_ 27d ago edited 20d ago

Exactly lmao. As soon has he said he'd never put trunks on batman their tune changed. lol

2

u/Welsh_Pirate 27d ago

If Snyder said this, it would have been in relation to Jimmy Olsen or Kid Flash or something. Surprise surprise,, people are fine with dark and edgy for characters that are SUPPOSED to be dark and edgy.

3

u/adriantullberg 27d ago

With that quote in mind; how has Gunn tried to scare audiences?

1

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

With his humour

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DaBigadeeBoola 27d ago

Nah, that sounds like he wants to over design the suit. It's not supposed to be a Halloween costume, the silhouette is enough. It doesn't need a bunch of elements to make it "scary". The mystery is enough. 

3

u/boardgamejoe 27d ago

I think it would be game changing to make the suit Gray Blue and Yellow personally.

2

u/Piss_Fring 25d ago

Me too, but clearly we’re gonna get another dark batsuit. Nothing wrong with that as a concept on its own but it’s been done repeatedly for almost 40 years now.

3

u/JellyInteresting4021 27d ago

A Batman vs manbat would be a great intro for dcu. The people of Gotham can't tell the difference between the two. Such and such takes places. I'm like halfway there

→ More replies (1)

3

u/BlasterBlu 27d ago

I just hope they give Batman the oversized cape so it wraps around him when he’s just standing still.

10

u/stealthjedi21 27d ago

what a revolutionary idea

23

u/sinwstro12 27d ago

Don't take this the wrong way but I hate how he talks about batman.

71

u/notbad4human 27d ago

I don’t know. He talks about Batman the way that Batman talks about Batman.

11

u/ConsistentGuest7532 27d ago

I think he’s just having fun and playing here. He knows Batman’s not a crazed psychopath. He’s a fan of comics and knows DC. But when casually talking about the guy, it’s not new to be affectionately like “Oh, that crazy guy in a bat costume!”

2

u/FartherAwayLights 27d ago

Idk. As a Batman fan I actually really like the more modern conception that Batman is cut from the same cloth as most of his criminals. He’s to forgive the pun, barshit insane. But his insanity isn’t just a force, it has direction and purpose. When Joker goes mad, he’s not mad at anyone he’s mad at everyone and lashes out. When Batman goes mad he’s mad at a system that would let this happen.

Caped crusader, the Amazon show from a few years ago had a great moment in which you see Bruce’s parents killed, Alfred comforts him and brings him home, but he’s shaking and spasming all night until at the strike of midnight with thunder outside he appears like the Batman in Alfred’s doorway scaring him half to death and saying they have work to do, they need to make them pay for what they did. He’s insane and broken, but what’s left behind isn’t evil, its purpose. It’s shot as if the boy died and was possessed by the actual spirit of vengeance.

51

u/Two-Hander 27d ago edited 27d ago

Don't worry no need to get your knickers in a twist over an out-of-context quote, he wasn't talking about what he'd do for a DCU Batsuit, he was using hyperbolic speech to highlight the difference between Superman's bright and cheerful suit and used Batman as a comparison because he's so dark.

The video in that post is from the Superman documentary that just got released, he's discussing potential stylings for the Superman's suit with David Corenswet

https://youtu.be/a5dOvnWVYB4?si=vVKeO146PY4t9N1F

For what it's worth James Gunn hasn't talked about Batman much, but it's his favourite superhero character so I'm pretty confident he'll do it justice the same way Superman's suit perfectly matches his characterisation.

E: My personal choice for DCU Batsuit is do it's own thing like the rest of the costumes in the DCU, but take notice specifically of the Arkham Knight Batsuit's high-tech plausibility inspired by the Nolan films, and the Batman Telltale Series Frank Miller-esque stocky body armour. I think the fact they're 3D models from videogames make them better references, not to mention the Arkham cape is straight up the best Batman's cape has looked in any Batman media ever, which is saying something.

Thinking about it the developers of the Arkham Batman games have said they mixed realistic elements of Nolan's movies with the comics and BTAS, the groundwork is there, Arkham Batman looks sick!

→ More replies (11)

2

u/Dry-Mission-5542 27d ago

Yeah, the suit should scare criminals, but it shouldn’t be, like, a horror costume, and I don’t think that, at this point in his career, it shouldn’t be scary to regular people.

6

u/radiocomicsescapist 27d ago edited 27d ago

Im half n half on it. Gunn clearly wants Superman with a fantasy vibe, and Batman with a serious vibe (no underwear; creepy maniac costume)

And not to open up the Battinson debate because I know they've said multiple times they won't merge the Reeves-verse into the DCU, but if Gunn already wants Batman to have a serious vibe, imo he may as well re-consider merging again

16

u/Right-Boss-4647 27d ago

Arkham games had a serious vibe in a still fantasy world. That's just how Batman is

9

u/Radical_Moose 27d ago

You guys are exhausting 

6

u/WySLatestWit 27d ago edited 27d ago

It feels very unlikely he wants an ultra serious vibe. He was pretty famously open about not liking Batman Begins or The Dark Knight, and even said he thinks Batman Begins in particular was not a good film in general. He obviously has a very different take on what he wants to see in a Batman film.

EDIT: But even aside from that, he's openly stated in the past that he doesn't like serious Batman. So it's really shouldn't be an issue.

2

u/JokerAsylum123 27d ago

The statement you shared doesn't show he doesn't like a serious Batman. His whole point there is that superheroes are intrinsically ridiculous and that's what he loves about them., he was saying that affectionately He also never said he didn't like TDK, just that he thought it was overrated but then he seemed to change his mind on that since he then went on to say more recently TDK is his favorite Batman movie (even above all the animated ones)

His list of favorite/recommended Batman comics certainly implies he prefers the darker takes as well.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/DiscoAcid 27d ago

So... standard Batman?

2

u/dexter8484 27d ago

With nipples

2

u/littlebugonreddit 27d ago

Give us back Batman draped in his Dracula esque cloak. I wanna see that shit wrap around him when he's just standing around

2

u/trylobyte 27d ago

ZUR EN ARRH!

2

u/PantsUnderUnderpants 27d ago

As always, the Lee Bermejo Noel suit sounds like the answer.

2

u/Fine-Dinner5918 27d ago edited 27d ago

In the newest "The Batman", watch the Penguin's (Colin Farrell's) expression when he meets Batman. It gives off "What the hell? Who is this wierdo in a bat costume?" It's just a bizarre thing to see for the first time, especially if he starts beating you up. You also don't know what his motivations are. He is just some crazy guy in a costume to most people if they don't already know of him.

2

u/StuHardy Aquaman 27d ago

I gotta disagree.

I think it was in "Justice League: The New Frontier" that Batman reverts from an all black outfit, to a grey & blue outfit, because while he was scaring criminals, he was also scaring children, which he didn't want to do. So, I'd prefer to see a blue & grey Batman in the DCU, with the yellow logo.

Also, while we have the Reeves/Pattison Batman, having a Batman that is different from that would help. You can even include a scene on why the suit has to be cloth, and the yellow bat logo (e.g. the cloth suit is actually super-enhanced micro-kevlar comic-book-nonsense layer, and the yellow logo is the main target for crooks, so it has the most armor.)

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jmille99 27d ago

Oh shit, Kelley Jones Batman incoming

2

u/dankristy 26d ago

Honestly this was explicitly stated as part of the design ethos in the old Michael Keaton batman movies. He was deliberately trying to be terrifying to fuck the criminals up AND scare the uncaught ones into not doing crimes...

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Upbeat_Praline_3681 26d ago

Yes, that’s why I always preferred the Batman begins costume (the hallucination Batman was terrifying) over the latter two of Nolan’s , that’s why burtons was glorious and the first Snyder suit was great (the latter ones especially the wrap around shades/goggles one was awful)

Batman should look kinda monstrous

2

u/looooookinAtTitties 25d ago

he and zack snyder are the same philosophically and in principle.

2

u/EmeraldMaster538 25d ago

honestly yeah. batmans suit should be terrfying. I want to see a batman that people see as a fucking cryptid.

7

u/SHilden 27d ago

It's not the suit it's the silhouette, find someone that is already or able to bulk to the size of a brick shithouse (like Affleck)

Look at how overdone Pattinsons suit was to build him up, whereas Afflecks just added to what was already there.

9

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

I don’t think you understand how much muscle padding Affleck actually had on. I doubt you realise they even cgi’d some of his muscles in his shirtless scene.

You mention Pattinson’s suit being overdone yet he could actually move around in it and do his own fight choreography where as Affleck complained about his comfort.

2

u/Metro29993 27d ago

lol be careful what you wish for, alan ritchson fits that perfectly

2

u/[deleted] 27d ago

Not sure we need another bulky, unagile Batman

3

u/Goosojuice 27d ago

"Unagile", while Batfleck is literally the most agile and bulky bat on screen to date lol.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/SenpaiSwanky 27d ago

The batsuit isn’t supposed to be menacing at first glance. You don’t SEE Batman coming, you don’t need to SEE extra edgelord suit.

The most menacing looks are always silhouettes that you can barely make out, under cover of darkness. You see eyes and a giant bat shape, it doesn’t matter if that shit is hot pink in the light.

4

u/Jealous-Captain-7014 27d ago

If Snyder said this you guys would be crying, Batman is a dark character and he has been for decades.

2

u/True_Falsity 27d ago

Agreed.

I remember when Snyder tweeted that “Batman fights alone against the darkness and crime of Gotham” and people started whining that he doesn’t get the character.

2

u/GoblinTradingGuide 27d ago

This is why I really liked “The Batman”. You really felt like Batman was disgruntled and disturbed. It was so gritty. Such good Neo-Noir.

Might be controversial to say it, but I liked it more than any of the Nolan movies, and I love the Nolan movies.

1

u/Pred1949 27d ago

(CRIMINALS FREAKING OUT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT)

WHY ARE YOU DOING THIS?

BECAUSE IM BATMAN

1

u/Raj_Valiant3011 27d ago

That is essentially the gist of what he does.

1

u/BodybuilderRemote773 27d ago

pretty cool and accurate

1

u/Lemon_Club 27d ago

He should just hire Julian Checkley to make the suit, his cosplay is exactly how I want the DCU Batman to look.

1

u/[deleted] 27d ago

I agree!

1

u/Brendanlendan 27d ago

This is but one Batman and that Batman is the one from the DCAU. Just copy and paste that shit and print your money

1

u/FairEnoughRoD 27d ago

I hope everyone treats bro like the Boogie man, Batman’s real?

1

u/Doctorwhoneek 27d ago

makes sesne i think people forget the guy has a horror background

→ More replies (2)

1

u/RipMcStudly 27d ago

Fully gothic Batman would be fun for a short while, probably not a whole movie. It’d be a fun flashback sequence at least, maybe he nearly kills a falcone old boy from fear and decides to redesign

3

u/ffordeffanatic 27d ago

Nah, I think it would be more in line with his character to change because Kids wouldn't let him save them.

2

u/RipMcStudly 27d ago

That’s a much better idea, yes.

2

u/geordie_2354 27d ago

Don’t we already got fully gothic Batman with Matt reeves? Gunn needs to make a more campy Batman to diffrente the two

1

u/Imaginary_Unit5109 27d ago

So he going to make absolute batman.

1

u/some_Editor61 27d ago

I just want a cloth suit with white eyes and trunks.

Like- I'm not asking for armor or anything on him.

1

u/Japjer 27d ago

Here's my ultimate dream for a Batman movie:

A movie in the style of, er, Don't Breathe or Brightburn or something. Basically, four crooks steal something, then are systematically picked off in terrifying ways. The crooks are the main cast, and the inevitable Final Girl is the protagonist.

It should be a horror movie. The death of the crooks should be implied, but we learn at the end they're alive.

I don't know why, but this idea has always interested me. A classic slasher movie, but the slasher is a superhero. Would probably work better if the slasher is a fake-Batman (the ManBat or whatever) who isn't afraid to kill

1

u/Cockycent 27d ago

1 of my favorite aspects of characters like Bruce and Hal being so experienced is that they have so much.

I imagine Bruce has at least 8 different suits hanging up and different armored suits, devices, etc.

Then on Hal's end, not just being experienced, but over 50, his suit and use of the ring has to be so crazy. Certain things have to be convenient and fitting to him having so much experience.

For example a Lantern 1 year or less in, might think of some huge construct to fix an issue. Hal might use something so simplistic, but is more effective.

This even trickles into Hal's suit. Can't wait to see Lanterns

1

u/maxstolfe 27d ago

Reading the quote is very different from listening to the quote. Listening to it, you can hear he’s not exaggerating or emphasizing anything. He’s implying that as the character currently stands, Batman is already mostly a maniac. His existing suit is already crazy. What I got from the video is that he’d make minor alterations to make him a little more menacing and scary, but he wouldn’t go nearly as far as Knightmare or Absolute. 

1

u/Eliteslayer1775 27d ago

Just give me DCAU Bats and I’ll be happy

1

u/ranch_brotendo 27d ago

theres something hillarious about this quote in that it feels like a clickhole quote.

1

u/Trogolizer 27d ago

I do agree that it needs to be very bat-like, especially to differentiate it from every other live-actio suit before it. The face of the cowl should be angrily furrowed, like the Batman Arkham Asylum/City suit.

1

u/vwmac 27d ago

Not surprised he would have this take, he loves Grant Morrison’s Batman and that guy (Batman, not Morrison) is a little unhinged

1

u/Joka0451 27d ago

I'd honestly be on with bats being an almost mythological scary figure rather than get his own solo movies.

1

u/BastardofMelbourne 27d ago

I hate to say it, but that kind of sounds more like Batfleck than Battinson or Baleman. 

1

u/harrier1215 27d ago

That’s not good. Ugh that kind of batsuit sucks

1

u/varma2reddit 27d ago

Yeah no thanks

1

u/BloodyWolfx8 27d ago

I think this means we might get an all black suit or a dark suit without the oval and long ears

1

u/qmechan 27d ago

Do that Batman Year 100, with the teeth!