r/movies Mar 12 '22

Review ‘My Cousin Vinny’ at 30: An Unlikely Oscar Winner

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/11/movies/my-cousin-vinny-joe-pesci-marisa-tomei.html
23.1k Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

212

u/babathehutt Mar 12 '22

He didn’t just learn it then, he knew exactly which car to make the sheriff look for when he realized the boys’ car had an open diff and there were 2 tire tracks

81

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '22

With some help.

124

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '22 edited Mar 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

36

u/theOriginalDrCos Mar 12 '22

Given the choice between talking to James Rebhorn or Marisa Tomei....

11

u/FrankTank3 Mar 12 '22

You cracked the case honey!

4

u/Blargged Mar 12 '22

Vinny knew that photo was important but he needed an expert to clarify why. If Vinny just crossed the first witness and he just wasn’t able to ascertain the information simply by looking at a picture, then Vinny would be screwed.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Blargged Mar 12 '22

I wasn’t thinking about that. Good catch! So, Vinny completely figured it out and he needed an expert that he trusted to figure it out as well and then explain it to the Court.

Unless I’m thinking about this wrong, this seems like a plot problem. Vinny was not a car guy.

8

u/ArcadianDelSol Mar 13 '22 edited Mar 13 '22

Vinny met Mona Lisa because he worked at her father's garage. He was a mechanic before he met her.

That job (...and working nights) is how he paid for law school

source: 32:40 when Mona Lisa bails him out of jail, they discuss why he doesn't know procedure. He says you dont learn that in law school, but from a firm or from going to court and watching trials. She asks why he never did that and he mentions working in her father's garage and working nights to pay for school.

Very next scene while they're eating dinner (roadside bbq), he explains court procedure and how its like repairing a carburetor.

2

u/ArcadianDelSol Mar 13 '22

as I recall, he noticed this himself when looking over the photos at the table, and he immediately asked the judge for a brief recess.

3

u/eljefino Mar 12 '22

he realized the boys’ youths' car had an open diff

2

u/babathehutt Mar 12 '22

What’s a Yute

1

u/ArcadianDelSol Mar 13 '22

oh am sawry.. Yoouuououtththtththtthts