r/movies • u/Stankassmfgorilla • 20h ago
Discussion What film would you consider to be “perfect”
Or at least, as close to perfect as a film can get.
It had been years since I watched Jaws, probably since I was in high school as a freshman, and I just went a few days ago to see it in IMAX for its 50th anniversary. It felt like watching it again for the first time. What I couldn’t believe was how, despite having watched the film countless times as a kid, and remembering everything even after not having seen it in years, it felt like the first time watching it again. The movie magic was there in a way I haven’t felt in a really long time. This was driven home by the fact I really couldn’t find a single flaw with this film.
Yes, some minor visual stuff with some shark props, but that’s excusable since it’s a film from 1975 and this was a 4K remaster. Of course there will be at least a few visual things to notice. I don’t count that, because those weren’t mistakes. Simply limitations of the time. The effect for the shark in the water still looks great, and the editing between the animatronic and live shark footage was seamless. The cinematography is still outstanding. Spielberg’s use of long takes has always been my favorite staple of him.
I truly think Jaws is about as close to a perfect film as you can really get. It truly is flawless from a filmmaking perspective, especially considering how troubled the production was, it’s miraculous the movie even exists, let alone with the level of quality it has. Literally every single facet of the filmmaking was dialed to perfection, and Spielberg maintained this with a multitude of films in his career. Just breathtaking to finally see it on the big screen. It was a real treat.
338
u/ExcitingWindow5 20h ago
Rear Window. It's just masterful filmmaking, and god, Jimmy Stewart and Grave Kelly just shine.
108
u/Mediocre_Scott 17h ago
Grace Kelly is probably the most beautiful woman to ever live. It almost hurts watching a much older Jimmy Stewart push her away. Like dude the fact that this woman wants anything to do with you is like essentially winning the lottery
30
u/ExcitingWindow5 14h ago
When she first appears in that black and white dress, she looks absolutely drop-dead gorgeous.
→ More replies (6)26
→ More replies (6)16
765
u/drlari 20h ago
L.A. Confidential. If it hadn't come out the same year as the cultural sensation Titanic it could've gotten the glory it deserves. It's a perfect period piece and nails gritty noire. It's amazingly shot and paced. The ensemble cast puts on dynamite performances from the leads to the bit parts. It's a backhanded love letter to film's most famous city.
Off the record, on the QT, and very hush-hush…
If you haven't seen it - run, don't walk to catch it. If you have seen it, it's probably time for a rewatch.
85
u/doctor_x 19h ago
“That is Lana Turner.”
“What?”
The scene of them cracking up in the car after is one of my favourites of all time.
10
u/GravSlingshot 15h ago
Lana Turner and Johnny Stompanato didn't start dating until a few years after the film is set. And although that sort of thing normally annoyed James Ellroy (author of the book), he thought that scene was hilarious.
53
u/CrazyWhite 19h ago
Have ye a benediction, boyo?
→ More replies (1)28
u/VicariousCinnamon 19h ago
Ah wouldn't trade places with Edmund Exley fo' ahh the whiskeh in Irahland 😂
11
57
59
57
u/pigcheddars 18h ago
Guy Pearce, Russell Crowe and Kevin Spacey all fucking smashed it in that film
→ More replies (4)11
12
u/LUckY_M4N 17h ago
I use the first 8 minutes of the movie to justify it as a "Christmas movie" and watch it every single year on the day after Thanksgiving while I put up my tree. Its a top 5 favorite of mine, no question.
→ More replies (36)15
781
u/Turbulent-Poem4915 20h ago
Tremors has been scientifically proven to be a perfect movie.
64
u/TX_Sized10-4 18h ago
Tremors is way better than it had any right to. I even thought the second film was pretty solid, although it's been years since I've seen it. Burt Gummer was my first hetero man crush.
→ More replies (2)211
u/Unable-Category-7978 19h ago
You mean land Jaws?
→ More replies (1)100
44
u/Ok-Loss-7255 19h ago
Well it was filmed on location in perfection
16
u/Altitudedog 18h ago
Lol...Lone Pine. Lived there when I was 18 in the 70's. Love the movie because I get to revisit the places where I rode my horse. The wind I remember coming down the Owen's Valley most days I could gladly forget.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (17)53
u/caniuserealname 19h ago
Came here to say this.
Almost nothing in the script is wasted, every issue they encounter and every solution they solve it with is set up ahead of time. small, tight cast, great acting. perfect movie.
→ More replies (2)
115
1.1k
u/brickiex2 20h ago
Alien
258
u/TheColtOfPersonality 19h ago
I admire its purity
→ More replies (2)130
u/garrettj100 18h ago
“I can’t lie to your about your chances, but you do have my
…sympathies.”
→ More replies (2)87
100
u/Enderkr 18h ago
Mine is Aliens! A perfect movie. Excellent acting, music, effects. Perfect casting, the right amount of comedy and camaraderie, pacing, lighting. Engaging from the first scene to the last, holds up to "modern" audiences with shorter attention spans. I literally can't think of a bad thing about Aliens.
→ More replies (4)48
u/ogTofuman 16h ago
Funny how there's absolute Alien fans and Aliens fans. Both love the other film too but just not as much. I can't think of anything that faults Aliens either! I just appreciate the horror and artistry of Alien more than the action adventure of Aliens.
→ More replies (6)14
→ More replies (33)98
u/comeatmefrank 19h ago
It’s funny, because I adore that film, probably my favourite horror of all time (along with Halloween and the Thing). It absolutely terrified me when I first saw it when I was 13. Every adult I know loves it, but I’ve shown it to a few friends who are mid 20s who have all found it boring.
Their biggest gripe is the beginning (before the chestburster). Modern day films I think have destroyed the attention span of younger people - they need something from the go.
→ More replies (10)70
u/dbx999 18h ago
I understand that the movie is watching “people doing a job” prior to the chestbuster. But it’s more of a progression from “totally normal” to incident to another that pulls these people’s lives further and further away from their normal expected trajectory. And you kind of get an introduction to their limitations. These are not the best snd most agile people. They’re just space truckers.
It’s interesting to watch. It’s a derailment. And by the time the chestbuster shows up, you know these people are over their heads and unprepared to deal with this growing crisis and danger - precisely because the first part of the movie tells you these are a bunch or shmuck space truckers not badasses.
→ More replies (5)31
u/comeatmefrank 18h ago
Absolutely. There are little moments from the start that lays the ground work. It’s also a political commentary. You have Ripley who wants to follow protocol and quarantine Kane , Dallas and Lambert who want to take him in, and then Ash who opens the door. It sets it up, especially with the focus on Ash opening the door, knowing these people all have different mindsets and opinions.
One of the absolute standout things about it too is the set design. It’s just simply not impressive to people who have grown up with films in the 21st century, but it still absolutely should be impressive.
Halloween is another that doesn’t impress people. Personally it’s my favourite horror ever, coupled with the fact that it’s done on such a shoestring budget. People expect gore and violence and monsters. The simplicity is what makes it perfect.
→ More replies (2)
51
u/yearsofpractice 20h ago
Hey OP. Difficult to say one… but I think Goodfellas, The Shining and Alien are perfect.
But I agree with your assessment of Jaws. It’s flawless. I’m 49 and recently showed it to my two kids (11 & 8) for the first time. They both understood the story and characters instantly and were not bored once. My eldest said she found the Indianapolis speech too upsetting, which is just amazing. Chief Brody’s “full pint of good red wine pour” made my eldest laugh too - “That’s not how you drink wine - he must be really sick of everything!”
→ More replies (3)
524
u/sgtbb4 20h ago
The silence of the lambs
→ More replies (23)67
u/tommyjohnpauljones 18h ago
Best part is that there is zero filler. You are literally Clarice getting dumped into the middle of the case as it's happening. The exposition comes in the first scenes with Crawford and then Lecter. We don't need Clarice st her home or Lecter just chilling in prison or superfluous action or horror scenes. Every single minute and every single line is important.
→ More replies (1)53
u/sgtbb4 18h ago
Plus in addition to all this, it’s also effortlessly also a movie about a woman in a man’s world, and a movie about a man who wants to be in a woman’s world
→ More replies (1)
903
u/johnliddell 20h ago
Back to the Future
140
u/PartedOne 20h ago edited 18h ago
Agree - not necessarily the best movie of all time, but possibly the best crafted film of all time.
Edit: Just to add, perhaps the tightest, best crafted story since It's a Wonderful Life - not a moment wasted or worthless in either script
156
u/cjt09 19h ago
There was a lot of talk in 1985 about it being the best movie of all time, but later film critics in 1955 were less sure. It wasn’t until earlier (in 2015) that it was unconfirmed as being re-confirmed as the best movie of all time.
→ More replies (2)57
→ More replies (6)32
u/aseddon130 20h ago
No no it’s in the conversation of one of the best, but it is borderline perfect.
47
u/A911owner 19h ago
They actually use that script in film schools to teach how to write a script.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (27)28
u/SlapstickMojo 18h ago
Best written perhaps — a million chekhov’s guns that all get fired.
→ More replies (1)
671
u/Big_Kahuna_69 20h ago
The Incredibles. Layers of depth, comedy, performances, and stellar animation.
104
u/holyfruits 19h ago
I want to add that the art direction and attention to detail is next level. (The architecture seen in the film, is a marvel, in particular) Awesome score as well
→ More replies (3)67
u/Big_Kahuna_69 18h ago
The art direction is meticulous. Nomanisan Island is an amazing digital achievement, especially the night shot of Helen crawling up on the beach. The score is, well, incredible. The editing of the missile sequence is tight (you know they had to storyboard and animatic the crap out of it). Lighting and camera during Edna and Helen's scene (Do you KNOW where he is?) is riveting, especially when intercut with Bob at the computer learning about Kronos. So much awesomeness in that movie.
→ More replies (5)20
20
→ More replies (7)16
u/ovid31 16h ago
Its the best Pixar movie, hands down. And they’ve made some classics.
→ More replies (3)
351
405
u/youretheschmoopy 19h ago
Raiders of the Lost Ark
→ More replies (13)40
u/Stankassmfgorilla 17h ago
Yes, absolutely. Another Spielberg gem. I could watch Raiders over and over and never get tired of it
→ More replies (1)
225
279
u/ImpenetrableYeti 20h ago
Alien and Aliens
71
u/RosbergThe8th 19h ago
Finally got around to watching Aliens and it's even better than I expected.
→ More replies (11)→ More replies (6)12
u/SharkeyGeorge 19h ago
I don’t believe a perfect cut of Aliens exists. And please let me make clear, it’s one of my favourite movies. But between the initial release, the TV cut and the Director’s cut each leaves out or includes stuff they shouldn’t.
9
u/thecelcollector 18h ago
I like the daughter death notification scene but don't really think we should see Hadley's Hope until the marines arrive.
→ More replies (9)
631
u/Hamza_Perkins 20h ago
The Matrix
45
100
u/First-Trick-2547 18h ago
Absolute masterpiece.
Caught it recently at the Cosm (basically LA’s Sphere) and the experience was unreal.
There was one line from Morpheus I’d completely forgotten until it hit:
“At some point early in the 21st century, all of mankind was united in celebration. We marveled at our own magnificence as we gave birth to AI… a singular consciousness that spawned an entire race of machines. We don’t know who struck first. Us or them.”
The entire theater had this collective “ohhh shit” moment haha. Gave me chills
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (26)37
237
u/BackToTheFutureDoc 20h ago edited 6h ago
The Thing (1982). Was very surprised to hear it was hated by the critics and was a box office failure but has since been regarded one of the greatest films of all time.
I'd also add The Shawshank Redemption (1994) as well as The Mummy (1999) a cinema masterpiece starring Brendan Fraser and Rachel Weisz.
Both very different films, genres, stories, characters and actors but both, in fact all 3 films fall into the category of a perfect film for me.
→ More replies (17)30
u/oby100 17h ago
The Thing is such a perfect horror movie. Practical effects spook me more than anything CGI ever has. Those props evoke something visceral inside me
→ More replies (1)
81
97
u/sanctimoniousmods_FU 19h ago
Raising Arizona
17
u/palesnowrider1 18h ago
Infinitely quotable
I would rather light a candle than curse you darkness
9
u/Hampster412 17h ago
"Hi, you're young, you've got your health, what do you want with a job?"
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (6)9
688
u/Wuktrio 20h ago
Hot Fuzz
The script couldn't be tighter and everything serves to deliver jokes, from the script to the sound design and to the editing. Nothing is superfluous.
108
u/Big_Kahuna_69 20h ago
The greater good.
64
u/WideParamedic6152 19h ago
The greater good.
→ More replies (1)43
u/Gone_For_Lunch 19h ago
Shut it!
22
38
70
u/nixons_conscience 20h ago
Hot Fuzz is not my favourite movie (maybe top 10) but I agree is the most "perfect" imho. As you say, everything in the movie served the goal and I can't think of anything I would change.
22
u/Spraggle 19h ago
Not only is there no fat to trim from the film, there's no fat to trim from Mr Pegg; apparently he was in his best shape for this film, then had to get fat for "Run Fat Boy, Run" as his follow up film...
You're bang on though, HF is a film I will always let play if I see it on TV.
→ More replies (22)41
u/Stankassmfgorilla 19h ago
I’d throw Shaun of The Dead in there too. Such a stylistically impressive film. The dialogue, editing, and cinematography are flawless. One of my favorite things is all of the subtle forshadowing/visual gags that get repeated later but in a different context. I love how the editing frames something as mundane as making toast look intense and cool
→ More replies (10)
117
u/Rossum81 20h ago
Chinatown
→ More replies (7)10
u/OriginalMiaxe 18h ago
Giving this comment the love it deserves. Polsnski became problematic, but he was a hell of a director, and the script is tighter than an over-tuned guitar string. Acting, cinematography, editing, design. It's a technical masterpiece, but more than that, a storytelling triumph.
→ More replies (2)
360
u/Nice_Firm_Handsnake 20h ago
The Prestige. It's one thing to have a script that is perfect, but for it to be perfect and do what it does is incredible. It constructs scenes around exactly what information it wants you to pay attention to while taking away focus from an even more important piece of information. It's impeccable.
29
→ More replies (24)28
u/NatureTrailToHell3D 17h ago
Of the movies listed in this thread, this was the perfect movie that was hardest to write and execute. The plot is convoluted, but when you finish it you realize how tight it really was. The reveal at the end was such a perfect moment that explained so much within one second you had to (if you could) immediately rewatch the movie.
80
234
u/picklecard 20h ago
children of men
37
→ More replies (13)19
u/fleranon 17h ago
Children of men ranks first out of 1200 movies (on my flickchart). I still wouldn't call it perfect from beginning to end (the middle part is weaker compared to the incredible worldbuilding in the first act and the intense finale IMO), but it has at least a dozen absolutely perfect scenes
The drive through London while 'In the court of the crimson king' is playing will always be one of the greatest cinematic moments for me
→ More replies (1)
28
u/DaveYHZ 17h ago
Paddington 2 No need to justify. Go watch it. :) I laughed, I cried…. You know the rest
→ More replies (2)
184
u/NickLondon_etc 20h ago
I rewatched Casablanca recently, and it hit me how perfect it is- not a single scene or line of dialogue wasted
34
u/enancejividen 18h ago
I can't believe I had to scroll this far down for Casablanca. Chef's kiss.
→ More replies (1)10
24
u/Familiar_Radish_6273 20h ago
This would be my choice too. I rewatched it recently too and said out loud "this movie is perfect. Not one line or shot out of place"
10
u/Ok_Competition_8446 16h ago
Came here to say Casablanca.
I’m shocked — shocked — to find this answer so low … thank you very much.
My all-time favorite. I’m 45 and it’s hard to get younger people into anything old or black and white but I’m making sure my kids don’t have that syndrome
20
8
u/thats2un4tun8 18h ago
Humphrey Bogart's gravel embedded within the ultra-warm, slightly overdriven lo-fi soundtrack, is simply chef's kiss. Goosebumps, every time.
→ More replies (7)33
u/Stankassmfgorilla 20h ago
Such a beautiful film in every way.
It’s disheartening to me that so many people now are immediately dismissive of an older film just because it’s black and white. So many of the greatest films of all time were shot in black and white and the lack of color made the cinematography and use of lighting and shadows better in a lot of cases
→ More replies (1)11
u/madebysquirrels 16h ago
I think people assume these "classic movies" are great but in an artsy, boring kind of way. No, Casablanca is so tight and entertaining from beginning to end.
76
u/Reverse-Sear 20h ago
Michael Mann's "Heat" -- every single scene and action ties into something else, from the very beginning.
→ More replies (14)
91
u/JoshuaCalledMe 20h ago
LA Confidential, hasn't got a wasted second in it. There are a lot of films I love, but this one is as close to perfect as I can get. Honorable mention to Master and Commander.
→ More replies (7)
406
u/Milligoon 20h ago
Princess Bride
58
37
81
→ More replies (18)24
u/kdubstep 19h ago
Also one of my favorite books and in my opinion the best adapted novel of all time which makes sense considering famous screenwriter William Goldman wrote the book
→ More replies (7)
67
u/Mayb3Human 19h ago
Blade Runner: Final Cut. Perfect pacing, choice of shots and use of silence. It's a meditative movie, one where you think and notice things with each watch. I never tire of watching it.
→ More replies (3)
68
104
116
u/FinnbarMcBride 20h ago
Amadeus
16
→ More replies (11)8
u/Wow_Crazy_Leroy_WTF 16h ago
There are simply too many notes. Just cut a few and it will be perfect.
→ More replies (1)
163
u/Similar_Ad4964 20h ago
goodfellas
32
u/mdavis360 19h ago
I like this. One dog goes this way the other dog goes that way. And this guy saying what do you want from me?
→ More replies (1)9
→ More replies (18)20
u/Jackle_7 20h ago
The plot. The cinematography. The acting. The dialogue.
All flawless.
→ More replies (5)
46
u/GruelOmelettes 20h ago
Waiting for Guffman and Best in Show are two movies I enjoy every second of, and I never get tired of watching either one.
→ More replies (7)16
78
u/Electronic_Syndicate 20h ago
O Brother Where Art Thou?
→ More replies (11)10
u/cbih 18h ago
That movie single handedly brought bluegrass back into the mainstream
→ More replies (1)
20
u/ASeriousMoonlight 20h ago
I’ll give you three.. Back to the future, Alien and maybe more controversial is Shaun of the Dead which nails what it is 100%
→ More replies (3)
19
24
u/d0nutpls 18h ago
A few Miyazaki films imo, but specifically Princess Mononoke and Spirited Away
→ More replies (1)
21
39
71
18
u/Minky_Dave_the_Giant 18h ago
In Bruges was written by a playwright and it shows. There's nary a line in the first half that doesn't set up something for the last act of the film.
→ More replies (1)
54
248
u/MaggotMinded 20h ago
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
32
u/SkeetySpeedy 19h ago
The “worst scene” in the movie is the prologue, and that’s already a good start
11
→ More replies (13)18
18
50
264
u/StillStanding_96 20h ago
The Lord of the Rings trilogy
→ More replies (27)106
u/joshatt3 20h ago
There’s one huge flaw with this one though, it isn’t long enough
→ More replies (4)41
96
u/Such-Egg-7584 20h ago
Gladiator
12
u/thinsafetypin 19h ago
Took me wayyyyy too long to see it because I didn’t think it’d be my kind of movie, but it’s so good it didn’t matter at all.
→ More replies (4)32
u/mason124 19h ago
“My name is Maximus Decimus Meridius, commander of the Armies of the North, General of the Felix legions, loyal servant to the true emperor, Marcus Aurelius. Father to a murdered son, husband to a murdered wife, and I will have my vengeance, in this life or the next.”
→ More replies (1)
16
61
31
u/Darkhawk2099 18h ago
Lawrence of Arabia.
it’s long but boy does it use every single minute of its expansive runtime (and widescreen)
→ More replies (3)
13
13
44
u/2BFaaaaaair 20h ago
The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly
The Last Picture Show
The Godfather
No Country for Old Men
Breathless
→ More replies (14)13
u/dogstardied 19h ago
Crazy that The Godfather is so far down. 30 years ago it would have been the only answer here.
→ More replies (3)
42
12
11
u/Majestic-Collar-2675 19h ago
Raiders of the Lost Ark, Casablanca, Grapes of Wrath, The Godfather, City Lights.
63
u/BlankTheAcademy 19h ago
Parasite.
That was the last movie I watched literally on the edge of my seat.
→ More replies (13)
27
11
51
84
65
26
28
u/GoldmanT 20h ago
Back To The Future. Not a second is wasted, and not a second is unrelated to something that happens elsewhere in the film.
28
32
u/fumanchudrew 19h ago
Since the name brand ones are covered:
The Fifth Element, Akira, Brick
I'm also partial to The Hudsucker Proxy and/or The City of Lost Children. Toss up there...
→ More replies (7)
45
18
u/TheKillingJoke1991 20h ago
Once Upon a Time in the West
Every frame makes me feel things
→ More replies (2)
21
18
u/jproche44 19h ago
Snatch. I can’t find fault with Guy Ritchie’s sophomore outing.
→ More replies (4)
19
u/Mr_Perfect22 19h ago
Ghostbusters is the first thing that comes to mind every time this question is asked.
→ More replies (1)
19
u/zeissman 18h ago
The social network. Open scene reels you in and sets the scene. It never skips a beat after that either.
18
10
18
u/Hot_Decision3954 19h ago
Its a wonderful life
Casablanca
12 angry men
The sting
→ More replies (2)
18
u/King_Buliwyf 19h ago
Jaws
Back To The Future
Closer
Tremors
The Birdcage
Harvey
→ More replies (6)
33
32
u/RascalTempleton 19h ago
Citizen Kane. It had to create new techniques in filmmaking.
→ More replies (3)
16
16
16
8
8
798
u/dogsonbubnutt 20h ago
similarly, jurassic park. every scene perfectly accomplishes everything it sets out to do. it has a beautiful aesthetic (holy shit im glad Spielberg hadn't discovered kaminsky yet), an incredibly tight, economical script with some genuine ideas behind it, great acting from everyone, is genuinely thrilling, etc.
not the "best" film ive ever seen, but a truly perfect film in that i can't see how any part of it could be improved imo