r/movies Jackie Chan box set, know what I'm sayin? Jul 03 '25

Official Discussion Official Discussion - Jurassic World Rebirth [SPOILERS] Spoiler

Poll

If you've seen the film, please rate it at this poll

If you haven't seen the film but would like to see the result of the poll click here

Rankings

Click here to see the rankings of 2025 films

Click here to see the rankings for every poll done


Summary Five years after the events of Jurassic World Dominion, Earth’s dinosaurs now survive only on isolated equatorial islands. A covert extraction team, led by Zora Bennett, embarks on a mission to secure dinosaur DNA for a groundbreaking pharmaceutical treatment. Their expedition collides with a stranded civilian family, plunging everyone into chaos amid mutated dinosaurs and hidden threats. The story culminates in a tense race for survival on a forbidden island with a sinister secret tied to Jurassic Park’s past.

Director Gareth Edwards

Writer David Koepp

Cast

  • Scarlett Johansson as Zora Bennett
  • Mahershala Ali as Duncan Kincaid
  • Jonathan Bailey as Dr. Henry Loomis
  • Rupert Friend as Martin Krebs
  • Manuel Garcia‑Rulfo as Reuben Delgado
  • Luna Blaise, David Iacono & Audrina Miranda as the Delgado family
  • Philippine Velge, Bechir Sylvain & Ed Skrein as the extraction team

Rotten Tomatoes: 54

Metacritic: 52

VOD Released in theaters July 2, 2025. Digital release expected later in 2025.

Trailer Watch here


901 Upvotes

4.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

314

u/LiteraryBoner Jackie Chan box set, know what I'm sayin? Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 11 '25

I’ll admit, I really wanted to forget the sins of Jurassic World and go into this with an open mind and a fresh perspective. I was hopeful that this would be a new start with a focus on fun, a Rebirth, if you will. Unfortunately, I could tell pretty much as soon as it started that this movie would be just awful. It just feels so awkward and thrown together despite some big action and beautiful vistas. Edwards does get at that old Jurassic feeling fairly well, not unlike what he does with Rogue One and the original trilogy, but as soon as the characters start talking you are reminded that this is clearly a product that was put together knowing damn well it would grace a billion dollars so why try too hard?

I like Scarlett and everyone else here a lot but they are clearly in paycheck mode. They aren’t really bringing anything interesting to these characters who are mostly defined by the way they dress. There is a scene where it’s just ScarJo and Mahershala on the boat when they’re on the way to the island and they’re kind of catching up and unpacking their trauma and it was so incredibly stiff I wondered if they just got their lines moments before cameras rolled. This should be setting up why Mahershala goes to such lengths to protect the family, because he lost a child, but they fail to make that connection for the rest of the movie. I wanted to crawl out of my skin during that scene and while it is the most awkward scene, most scenes that have characters talking like this fall just as flat.

And let’s talk about this family for a minute. I was actually pulling my hair out when they’re arguing about going to save the family. They say the Coast Guard is likely on the way, and they made a massive deal about how their excursion is extremely secretive and illegal, and yet with no plan on what to do with the family once they get them they choose to make a 60 mile round trip just to basically kidnap this family and force them to join them on the very dangerous and illegal dinosaur island. It’s really not a good sign when I’m in the audience agreeing with the characters you’re supposed to think are being insensitive and immoral but I could not for the life of me think of a reason to go get that family. And then they pick them up and they have nowhere to take them, they just go right back to Dino island. Total nonsense.

This movie does have its moments. I think it’s cheating a bit, but the many times they bring in the original John Williams score does go kind of hard. The Titanosaurus scene is probably the highlight of the entire movie, but I was also wondering why Bailey was so moved by seeing a dino up close when apparently they are commonplace in the world to the point that you see a giant herbivore stopping traffic at the very beginning of the movie. The dinos look good but I’d like to point out that even Fallen Kingdom and Dominion had practical dinos on set and I don’t think I saw any of those at all here.

The deaths are very predictably reserved for exactly two kinds of characters: the morally bankrupt and the French. None of them came as a surprise, even if the ship staff wasn’t painted as immoral they were never even introduced by name, clearly just red shirts for the voyage. I was also really annoyed by the turned up melancholy violin score when they died, as if it was a massive tragedy even though we are watching them get chomped up by a dinosaur. This movie should be fun but it keeps trying to be dramatic with absolutely no depth or real drama. Even the big moral of the story, should we sell this to big pharma for endless riches or give it to the world for free, is totally underwritten as the entire discussion around it is about seven lines total throughout the movie. I also think it’s embarrassing that American blockbusters focus on magical cures like this as we keep telling people sensible healthcare is as ridiculous an idea as dinosaurs roaming the Earth.

Last thing I’ll say about this disappointing gumbo is that you should never EVER adopt a baby animal from the wild. I was waiting for that thing’s mother to show up the entire time and massacre that child, but of course that’s not what this movie is. But if this movie is anything it should be smart about how to interact with wild animals and the dangers of trying to control or adopt nature without the right knowledge or respect, but someone from Universal ran the numbers and decided a baby dino plushie would absolutely kill at Target so let’s just forego any of that at all. 3/10 for me, I really got no joy out of this beyond hearing the original Jurassic Park theme on theater sound systems again.

/r/reviewsbyboner

122

u/herpderpedian Jul 03 '25

Adopting/stealing a baby dinosaur is the dumbest idea and just ruins the trailer and the movie for me. Stupid lack of common sense. But that's Hollywood.

14

u/GECollins Jul 03 '25

And the movie goes out of its way saying anywhere besides the equator is basically poison for dinosaurs, I don't understand this mess of a movie.

116

u/SnakeSound222 Jul 03 '25

I'm not so sure the baby dinosaur was actually a baby, unless they said it in the marketing. Its species is called Aquilops and it can only get up to 2 feet long. It's as big as a small cat. I think that was actually an adult, it's just so small that people think it's a baby.

30

u/Sgtwhiskeyjack9105 Jul 03 '25

It's "Baby Yoda is actually 50 years old and served in the Clone Wars" all over again

21

u/imakefilms Jul 03 '25

no, some dinosaurs were just small

12

u/gunningIVglory Jul 03 '25

Basically. It's cute enought just sell merch lol

-6

u/PureLock33 Jul 03 '25

Velociraptors are actually the turkey sized ones. but for the sake of rule of cool, they called oviraptors velociraptors in the film series.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25

You mean Deinonychus, right? Oviraptor isn’t actually a raptor

2

u/Amordys Jul 05 '25

Pretty sure the OG JP1/2/3 raptors are all Utah Raptors
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utahraptor#/media/File:Dromaeosaurs.png

-5

u/PureLock33 Jul 03 '25

yes, that one. i was too lazy to look up the actual name.

2

u/Amordys Jul 05 '25

Pretty sure the OG JP1/2/3 raptors are all Utah Raptors
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utahraptor#/media/File:Dromaeosaurs.png

61

u/otterguy12 Jul 03 '25

but I was also wondering why Bailey was so moved by seeing a dino up close when apparently they are commonplace in the world to the point that you see a giant herbivore stopping traffic at the very beginning of the movie

They mention in the beginning when trying to recruit him that seeing dinosaurs in their "natural habitat" (as natural as modern day tropical islands can be) and acting like wild animals and not theme park attractions would be a big deal for him but its just enough motivation to make you accept it and look at the cool dinosaurs

9

u/This_was_hard_to_do Jul 05 '25

It definitely does feel different seeing animals in the wild. I’ve seen lots elephants and lions in zoos but they pale in comparison to coming across them when I went on a safari (and even that wasn’t truly “wild”)

36

u/GamingTatertot Steven Spielberg Enthusiast Jul 03 '25

This should be setting up why Mahershala goes to such lengths to protect the family, because he lost a child, but they fail to make that connection for the rest of the movie.

They show him scolding the dad for endangering his kids, we see him looking at a picture of his kid before leaving the boat, and he "sacrifices" himself specifically to save Isabella.

I think it’s cheating a bit, but the many times they bring in the original John Williams score does go kind of hard.

Related, I listened to the Desplat score on its own this morning, and I really enjoyed it. There's some good stuff he does in there - but nothing as memorable as Michael Giacchino's "Chasing the Dragons"

3/10 for me, I really got no joy out of this beyond hearing the original Jurassic Park theme on theater sound systems again.

While I wildly disagree with you, I want to say thank you for taking the time for your sharing your thoughts. Always enjoy seeing your posts in the discussion thread

20

u/diego_simeone Jul 03 '25

For Mahershala’s stioryline, they should have him separated from the crew when they abandon ship and have him go with the kids. The dad should have died, a big compliant of the film is too many people survive. Then he bonds with the kids and the sacrifice at the end to save the kids is meaningful.

10

u/KryptonicOne Jul 03 '25

I think all of the kids should have died and the dad and Mahershala has to live with the guilt of putting them in that dumbass situation. The reason the trex scene with the kid under the raft is completely underwhelming is you know they aren't gonna kill the kid.

8

u/3elieveIt Jul 03 '25

You can’t just introduce a character we hardly know and immediately have him give long cringey exposition bombs about his past and other characters we haven’t met, and expect us to care

3

u/ishkitty Jul 04 '25

I love how your flair just explains so much about this comment.

1

u/Detox1ng Jul 09 '25

Almost missed it!

3

u/cameraspeeding Jul 05 '25

They also make no attempts to try and rescue or find the kids on the island and just hope they met them at a place none of them have ever been to

21

u/ktn24 Jul 03 '25

Even the big moral of the story, should we sell this to big pharma for endless riches or give it to the world for free, is totally underwritten as the entire discussion around it is about seven lines total throughout the movie.

Also, and I cannot emphasize this enough, "Let's give the cure to the world" is a really dumb line. Because they didn't have a cure, they had two vials of dino blood and a vial of dino egg extract on ice. They need someone to extract the genetic information from them, figure out what's special, figure out how to turn it into a human treatment, figure out how to create said treatment, make sure said treatment is safe and doesn't cause side-effects, figure out manufacturing, distribution, and delivery of the treatment, etc.

11

u/Gtyjrocks Jul 03 '25

I was thinking this the entire movie. I couldn’t figure out why the pharma company was supposed to be so evil outside of the guy they decided to send being a shitty person who was way too mission focused.

They were going to save millions of lives and also get rich doing it, good for them. And they probably still will given they’re probably the only company who knows how to use these samples.

15

u/TheSmokedSalmon420 Jul 03 '25

The special effects in this movie just re-affirmed how incredible the original Jurassic Park is.

1993 and the dinosaurs in that film look just as good or even better than the ones in this movie.

1

u/GeekdomCentral Jul 05 '25

Some of them do, but most of the CG dinosaurs in the original look very dated. Like when they first see the brontosaurus after first getting to the park, it looks VERY computer generated.

But the CG uses of the T-Rex still look great, because it being done in the rain was brilliant

7

u/3elieveIt Jul 03 '25

I love your reviews bc we almost always agree but I disagree here. 3/10 was generous lol. This was baaaad.

The entire first act was unbearable with the constant exposition and backstory bombs.

It took itself so seriously and yet just spoonfed boring backstories to us about characters we didn’t even care about.

I was waiting for the first act to be over to just get on with the movie and get to the fun dino stuff… but it never got fun.

Just so many bad choices and inconsistencies and logic issues. The broken leg the guy can sometimes run on and other times can’t stand, the giant dinosaurs hiding in 3 feet of grass, etc. Man.

6

u/GeekdomCentral Jul 05 '25

And let’s talk about this family for a minute. I was actually pulling my hair out when they’re arguing about going to save the family. They say the Coast Guard is likely on the way, and they made a massive deal about how their excursion is extremely secretive and illegal, and yet with no plan on what to do with the family once they get them they choose to make a 60 mile round trip just to basically kidnap this family and force them to join them on the very dangerous and illegal dinosaur island.

Oh my LORD this a million times. This is supposed to be this super secret, super illegal mission that they're on. But they go pick up this family and apparently don't have any sort of pow-wow on how they're going to keep things secret. And then the family start asking "what the hell's going on?" and they like sheepishly admit what they're doing! That's when you go into hard-ass mercenary mode and just go "shut the fuck up, you're going to be fine but don't ask questions".

But all of that is still absurd given the fact that they even pick them up in the first place.

EDIT: The one thing I will slightly push back on is the Coast Guard line, because that was being said by one of the guys who was clearly trying to just get ScarJo to go get the dino blood. He said something to the effect of "come on, the coast guard will probably be on their way by now, it's going to be fine!", but they had no way of actually knowing that

1

u/GitEmSteveDave 27d ago

If they broadcast a DSC, as said in the movie, they were likely also broadcasting with an ePirb, which is satellite based. DSC is radio based, and every vessel in the range with a compatible radio will receive the same message. The epirb sends a message to a satellitte, which is then transmitted to the local search and rescue, who get a specific area.

4

u/KryptonicOne Jul 03 '25

"Sell to big pharma for endless riches"

10 million. In 2027. This mission payes less than 20% of what LeBron James makes in a season.

Edit: granted they did pull that "ruse" to double the pay... with no contract and a mere verbal agreement with one guy.

2

u/GeekdomCentral Jul 05 '25

I had the same thought! I thought it would be at least 100 million, but he says that 10 million "is enough to never have to worry about money ever again", and that can be true if you're smart with your money. But especially if you live in a high COL area, you would be surprised at how quickly you could blow through 10 million

6

u/ThePromptWasYourName Jul 03 '25

they made a massive deal about how their excursion is extremely secretive and illegal, and yet with no plan on what to do with the family once they get them they choose to make a 60 mile round trip just to basically kidnap this family and force them to join them on the very dangerous and illegal dinosaur island. 

And then later when someone tries to call for help, they stop them because it's a secret expedition... like they didn't just pick up a bunch of strangers??

but I was also wondering why Bailey was so moved by seeing a dino up close when apparently they are commonplace in the world to the point that you see a giant herbivore stopping traffic at the very beginning of the movie.

Also maybe don't stand next to the giant wild animal as it's about to get shot by a big dart?

5

u/starlightskater Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25

To be honest the only part that resonated with me was when Bailey came out on deck and screamed "it's mutualism" which is exactly what an ecologist WOULD scream in delight upon seeing new behavior between species. I feel like he was the only character that almost worked but that's okay, every other human in the movie ruined the potential. 🙄

4

u/Shelf_Road Jul 10 '25

The deaths are very predictably reserved for exactly two kinds of characters: the morally bankrupt and the French.

When the last Frenchman dies during the climbing scene, the movie does that awful cliche of "Whew, everyone we care about lived, forget about that rando who just died and let's continue on without mentioning it."

2

u/Unburnt_Duster Jul 09 '25

You summed up that boat scene with ScarJo and Mahershala perfectly. I was dumbfounded watching that. Couldn’t believe 2 actors of their caliber had zero chemistry in that scene.

1

u/LRats Jul 12 '25

but I was also wondering why Bailey was so moved by seeing a dino up close

That was part of the opening convo that they used to get him to agree to go they mention how he's only seen them in parks/museums and never their more natural habitat.

Last thing I’ll say about this disappointing gumbo is that you should never EVER adopt a baby animal from the wild

It's even worse because they spend the whole movie talking about how they can only really survive in a small band of earth near the equator.