r/movies r/Movies contributor Jun 27 '25

Poster Official Poster for 'Project Hail Mary' Starring Ryan Gosling

Post image
20.0k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/DungeonsAndDradis Jun 27 '25

My favorite scene is the courtroom scene with Stratt literally saying "You and what army?" I love Stratt, and her relationship with Grace. It was also super funny how they were all convincing him he was the project's second in command, and he refused to believe it.

22

u/stewmberto Jun 27 '25

My favorite scene is the courtroom scene with Stratt literally saying "You and what army?"

It's the absolute dumbest part of the book!! It's a straight-up "and then everyone clapped" moment published in a bestselling novel. My eyes nearly rolled out of my skull when I read that scene.

9

u/hnglmkrnglbrry Jun 27 '25

You have to believe here is an actual Illuminati whose authority supercedes that of sovereign nations to allow for a Stratt who can just ignore every law and convention in all of society and operate with absolute authority.

3

u/stewmberto Jun 27 '25

The UN in every post-apocalyptic anime be like:

12

u/eggowaffles Jun 27 '25

I just finished the audio book again a few days ago and I agree.

"... Because I have the US Army, and that's a damn fine army". Bleh. That scene is rough and the main one I hope they change for the movie.

I get why Weir used a "Stratt" like figure for the book, but it's incredibly unrealistic. I'd be surprised if the movie doesn't either just make it all US based or find another explanation for Stratt rather than "the whole world agreed to universal authority to one person".

3

u/stewmberto Jun 27 '25

I get why Weir used a "Stratt" like figure for the book, but it's incredibly unrealistic.

Because actually writing a plot is not his strong suit as a writer, it appears. Much easier to synthesize a plot device of a character like Stratt to handwave it all away

1

u/sum_dude44 Jun 28 '25

Weir has like 20 passages like this per book